Skip to main content
πŸ“– The AI Tool Bible

OpenAI Evals vs Promptfoo

A side-by-side look at pricing, capabilities, pros, cons, and our editorial scores.

Tagline
OpenAI Evals
β€”
Promptfoo
Open-source eval and red-teaming framework for LLM apps, prompts, and RAG pipelines.
Pricing
OpenAI Evals
Free
Promptfoo
FreemiumΒ· Free tier
Free trial
OpenAI Evals
Not listed
Promptfoo
Yes
API
OpenAI Evals
Not listed
Promptfoo
Yes
Platforms
OpenAI Evals
cli
Promptfoo
cliapi
Open source
OpenAI Evals
Yes Β· NOASSERTION
Promptfoo
Yes Β· NOASSERTION
GitHub stars
OpenAI Evals
19,734
checked 2026-11-13
Promptfoo
23,011
checked 2026-11-13
Last GitHub push
OpenAI Evals
2026-04-14
Promptfoo
2026-08-28
First commit
OpenAI Evals
2023-01
Promptfoo
2024-05
Package downloads (30 d)
OpenAI Evals
650 Β· pypi evals
checked 2026-11-19
Promptfoo
β€”
Hacker News stories
OpenAI Evals
β€”
Promptfoo
23
checked 2026-11-19
Earliest Wayback capture
OpenAI Evals
β€”
Promptfoo
2023-05-20
earliest archived capture of the site, not a launch date
Company
OpenAI Evals
OpenAI
Promptfoo
OpenAI
Model used
OpenAI Evals
OpenAI GPT models (extensible)
Promptfoo
Multi-model
Best for
OpenAI Evals
β€”
Promptfoo
Pick Promptfoo if you ship LLM features to production and want versioned evals, regression tests, and automated red-teaming in CI.
Not for
OpenAI Evals
β€”
Promptfoo
Skip it if you just need a chat playground or a no-code prompt comparison tool with zero setup.
Editorial score
OpenAI Evals
8.1 / 10
Promptfoo
7.2 / 10
Use cases
OpenAI Evals
Evaluating LLMs and LLM systemsTesting different dimensions of OpenAI modelsPrompt chains and tool-using agentsBuilding basic or model-graded evals
Promptfoo
llm-evalsred-teamingprompt-regressionrag-testingai-securityci-cd-guardrails
Pros
OpenAI Evals
  • Includes an existing registry of evals to test different dimensions of OpenAI models
  • Allows users to write custom evals for specific use cases
  • Allows building basic or model-graded evals without writing evaluation code
  • Supports running and creating evals using Weights & Biases
Promptfoo
  • Genuinely open source and self-hostable, not a fake-OSS funnel
  • Model-agnostic; works across OpenAI, Anthropic, local, custom APIs
  • Red-teaming covers prompt injection, jailbreaks, PII, policy violations
  • Clean CI integration with GitHub/GitLab/Jenkins for regression catching
  • Large community and Fortune-500 adoption signal staying power
Cons
OpenAI Evals
β€”
Promptfoo
  • YAML-heavy config has a learning curve for non-engineers
  • Enterprise pricing is opaque (contact sales only)
  • Red-team scans can be slow and token-expensive at scale
Website
OpenAI Evals
github.com
Promptfoo
promptfoo.dev

Editorial score: rule-based, 0–10, from AI-assisted profile inputs (see /methodology) β€” not a user rating; β€œβ€”β€ means unscored. β€œNot listed” means we have no record of it, not that it is absent. GitHub figures and prices carry the date they were checked or captured; prices are shown as published, unconverted.

Pick OpenAI Evals if
  • βœ… Includes an existing registry of evals to test different dimensions of OpenAI models
  • βœ… Allows users to write custom evals for specific use cases
  • βœ… Allows building basic or model-graded evals without writing evaluation code
  • βœ… Supports running and creating evals using Weights & Biases
Pick Promptfoo if
  • βœ… Genuinely open source and self-hostable, not a fake-OSS funnel
  • βœ… Model-agnostic; works across OpenAI, Anthropic, local, custom APIs
  • βœ… Red-teaming covers prompt injection, jailbreaks, PII, policy violations
  • βœ… Clean CI integration with GitHub/GitLab/Jenkins for regression catching