Skip to main content
πŸ“– The AI Tool Bible

How we rate and source-check

Every tool page carries three separate things: profile facts, a source-check status and, for most tools, a 0–10 score. This page explains each one and where its limits are. Written by the AI Tool Bible editorial team; see the editorial policy for who we are and how AI is used.

The 0–10 score

The score is a rule-based score with AI-assisted inputs: a fixed formula run over what is recorded on the profile, where the profile text itself (description, pros and cons, best-for, editor's take) was drafted with AI assistance. It is not a user rating, not an average of reviews, not a benchmark result and not a hands-on test. 697 of 1,020 tools have a score.

The historical formula started every tool at 5.0 and added points for signals on the profile. The result was never below 5.0 or above 9.6:

  • Verification status β€” +1.0 if the tool carried the now-retired "editorially verified" label. That label has been withdrawn (see below), but the stored scores still include this bonus.
  • Featured flag β€” +0.5 if the tool is featured.
  • Description length β€” +0.3 for every 500 characters of description beyond the first 500, up to +1.2 in total.
  • Pros listed β€” +0.2 for 3 or more, +0.4 for 5 or more, +0.6 for 7 or more.
  • Cons listed β€” +0.3 for 2 or more, +0.4 for 4 or more.
  • Pricing detail β€” +0.3 if a pricing-detail note of more than 20 characters is recorded.
  • Best-for, not-for and editor's take β€” +0.5 if all three fields are filled in.
  • Open source β€” +0.1 if the code is open source.
  • API β€” +0.1 if the tool has an API.

So the score mostly measures how completely a profile is documented, plus a one-point bump for the retired verified label and half a point for featured. A thoroughly documented tool can outscore a better product with a thin write-up, and the score does not measure capability, quality or recent activity. The scores are historical: no scheduled job recalculates them, and we have not changed any score value. We will revisit the scores after the profiles have been re-grounded in the vendors' own pages. A small gap between two scores is not a meaningful difference. Treat the score as a way to shortlist, not as a verdict.

What "unscored" means

323 tools have no score. Unscored does not mean a low score or a zero. It means we have not assigned one, and we do not estimate or back-fill a score to fill the gap. In ranked lists, unscored tools sort after scored ones.

Source-checked profiles

542 of 1,020 profiles are currently source-checked.

  • Text source-checked <date> β€” on that date the profile's description, pros, limitations (when the vendor states any) and editor's take were rebuilt from verbatim quotes of the vendor's own pages, and each quote was found on the fetched page. Facts such as API, open source, platforms and pricing tier show "(not source-checked)" unless a quote supports them. A source-checked profile may list no limitations, and may have no "Best for" line, because the vendor's pages state none; we leave the gap rather than fill it. It is not a claim that we have used the product hands-on. The label appears only for profiles that have been through that process.
  • Not yet source-checked (478) β€” drafted by software from the vendor's website and public sources and not yet checked against them. Treat the text as machine-drafted and unverified, and confirm details with the vendor.
  • Link check failing (19 marked stale) β€” the website failed our link check on three consecutive checks, or redirects to an unrelated domain. The profile may describe a product that has changed or closed.

Why we retired "editorially verified". On 21 October 2026 we compared a random sample of 60 profiles with the vendors' own websites. A sample check found errors in most of the older profiles, and the profiles that carried an "editorially verified" badge were no more accurate than the machine-drafted ones. The badge only meant a profile had passed internal promotion checks (a known source, a live website, a category and pricing tier), which does not show the prose is correct. We withdrew the badge and every claim built on it, and we are rebuilding every profile from verbatim quotes of the vendors' own pages. Until a profile shows "Source-checked <date>", treat its text as machine-drafted and unverified.

Link checks

An automated job checks tool websites every night, up to 20 tools per day, always taking the tools checked longest ago (never-checked first). At that rate one full pass over 1,020 tools takes about 51 days. The most recent check recorded in our database was on 2026-11-22.

  • A response in the 200s, or a redirect that stays on a related domain, counts as alive and resets the failure counter.
  • A redirect to an unrelated domain, an error response, a DNS or TLS failure or a timeout adds one to the failure counter. Three in a row mark a tool stale. Some tools are exempt from automatic demotion to stale, so their internal status can stay the same however many checks fail; any tool page whose website has failed three or more checks in a row shows a "Link check failing" badge regardless.
  • Responses 403, 429, 503 and 530 are treated as unknown, not dead. Those usually mean a bot-protection layer refused our request, so the status and counter are left unchanged.

A passing check shows the website answered. It does not show that the profile text is still accurate.

Pricing and capture dates

Where a tool page shows a pricing table, it comes from a stored capture of the vendor's pricing page and carries the date it was fetched. Only some tools have a capture, and a vendor may have changed prices since. The most recent capture in our database is dated 2026-11-22. The pricing label on a tool (free, freemium, paid, enterprise) is a summary, so confirm current prices with the vendor.

AI-generated summaries

The short "In short" summaries and FAQ answers on tool pages are AI-written from the profile's own fields. Each answer must pass an automated check that it shares at least three content words with the source fields, which catches some invented content but is not a fact-check. Details are in the editorial policy.

Lifecycle tracking

When a tool is confirmed shut down, acquired or renamed, the change is recorded with a source link and date. Those tools are listed on Discontinued, acquired and renamed tools with pointers to alternatives. Name changes are also listed on Renames & rebrands.

Corrections

If a profile, score or price is wrong, email us via the contact page with the tool name and what should change. Vendors can write in the same way.