Hacker News MCP vs Reddit MCP (adhikasp/mcp-reddit)

Hacker News MCP

MCP Servers

Reddit MCP (adhikasp/mcp-reddit)

MCP Servers

Tagline

Hacker News MCP

MCP server that lets Claude and other LLM clients read Hacker News stories, comments, users, and search results

Reddit MCP (adhikasp/mcp-reddit)

MCP server that lets Claude and other LLM clients fetch and analyse Reddit threads

Pricing

Hacker News MCP

Free· Free and open-source (MIT). No API keys or accounts required — hits the public Hacker News API and Algolia HN Search directly.

Reddit MCP (adhikasp/mcp-reddit)

Free· Free and open source (MIT). No paid tier. You run it locally; Reddit's public JSON endpoints are hit unauthenticated, subject to Reddit rate limits.

Open source

Hacker News MCP

Yes · MIT

Reddit MCP (adhikasp/mcp-reddit)

Yes · MIT

GitHub stars

Hacker News MCP

76

checked 2026-10-29

Reddit MCP (adhikasp/mcp-reddit)

434

checked 2026-10-29

Last GitHub push

Hacker News MCP

2025-07-14

Reddit MCP (adhikasp/mcp-reddit)

2025-05-11

First commit

Hacker News MCP

2024-12

Reddit MCP (adhikasp/mcp-reddit)

2024-12

Best for

Hacker News MCP

Claude Desktop, Cursor, or Cline users who want their assistant to read Hacker News front pages, comment threads, and search results as part of a broader research or coding workflow.

Reddit MCP (adhikasp/mcp-reddit)

Developers and researchers who already use an MCP-capable assistant and want the model to pull live subreddit discussions into a session without wiring up the Reddit API themselves.

Not for

Hacker News MCP

Teams that need to post to HN, moderate submissions, or run high-volume server-side HN analytics — this is a local, read-only stdio tool, not a hosted API.

Reddit MCP (adhikasp/mcp-reddit)

Teams that need to write to Reddit, run scheduled scrapes at scale, do historical/full-text search, or comply with a formal Reddit API data-use agreement.

Editorial score

Hacker News MCP

—

Reddit MCP (adhikasp/mcp-reddit)

—

Use cases

Hacker News MCP

Daily Hacker News front-page digest inside ClaudeSummarising the comment thread on a specific Show HN or Ask HNKeyword search across HN history from within an LLM chatProfiling a user's recent submissions and commentsChaining article fetch + comment analysis with a browser MCPTrend spotting across top / new / ask / show feedsReference implementation for building your own read-only MCP wrapper

Reddit MCP (adhikasp/mcp-reddit)

Subreddit hot-thread summarisationCommunity sentiment monitoringProduct feedback harvesting from niche subredditsCompetitive intelligence on brand mentionsResearch assistant grounding on live discussionsDaily digest of r/LocalLLaMA or r/programmingComment-thread analysis for a specific postPrep material before drafting a Reddit reply

Pros

Hacker News MCP

• Zero-config: no API key, no account, works against the public HN and Algolia endpoints out of the box
• Covers the four things people actually want from HN in an LLM context — front pages, comment threads, search, and user activity
• One-line install via Smithery, or a two-line `uvx` entry in any MCP client config
• Composes cleanly with other MCP servers (README shows a Puppeteer + HN chain for article + comments summaries)
• MIT-licensed and small enough to fork or self-host without ceremony
• Because it's local stdio, no HN data flows through a third-party relay

Reddit MCP (adhikasp/mcp-reddit)

• One-line install via Smithery or uvx; no API keys or OAuth to configure
• Open source under MIT, ~400 GitHub stars, actively maintained by the author
• Works with any MCP host — Claude Desktop, Cursor, mcp-client-cli, Continue, etc.
• Handles text, link and gallery post types, plus nested comment threads
• Runs locally, so prompts and fetched content never touch a third-party service
• Tiny surface area makes it easy to audit, fork, or extend

Cons

Hacker News MCP

• Read-only — no submit, upvote, flag, or comment actions (an intentional but real limitation)
• Small maintainer surface (single-author repo, sporadic updates) so bugs may sit
• No caching or pagination controls beyond what the underlying HN/Algolia APIs offer; large comment trees can blow out an LLM context window
• Only useful inside an MCP-capable client — not a standalone CLI or HTTP service
• Search quality is bounded by Algolia HN Search; nuanced semantic queries still miss things a human scroll would catch

Reddit MCP (adhikasp/mcp-reddit)

• Read-only — cannot post, comment, vote, or perform moderation actions
• Uses Reddit's public JSON endpoints unauthenticated, so it inherits their rate limits and can be blocked on heavy use
• No historical or full-text search across Reddit; scope is hot threads and specific posts
• Requires a working Python/uv toolchain and a client that already speaks MCP
• Not an official Reddit product, so any Reddit API policy change can break it without warning

Website

Hacker News MCP

github.com

Reddit MCP (adhikasp/mcp-reddit)

github.com

Editorial score: rule-based, 0–10, from AI-assisted profile inputs (see /methodology) — not a user rating; “—” means unscored. “Not listed” means we have no record of it, not that it is absent. GitHub figures and prices carry the date they were checked or captured; prices are shown as published, unconverted.